When you give a thought to roof replacement or think that it's time to replace your roof, the very first question popping into your head will be "Which type of shingle you should choose?" And if we talk about the most commonly available options then there are two only—3-tab shingles and architectural shingles. Both these options serve the basic purpose of keeping your house protected but have some significant differences in terms of looks, longevity, and end value.
But here's how they stack up against each other up close — and why architectural shingles should be the winner for most homeowners.
Appearance and Curb Appeal
3-Tab Shingles
3-tab shingles are smooth on both the front and back and have just 1 layer of asphalt. Though functional, they provide a plain appearance which does very little to enhance a home's exterior. 3-Tab also comes with less color options, as manufacturers mostly make architectural shingles these days.
Architectural Shingles
Also called laminated or dimensional shingles, architectural shingles offer a richer, multidimensional appearance thanks to multiple layers in the visible part of each shingle. They can replicate cedar shakes or slate, to make your house feel a little nicer-nice. There are many styles and colors of architectural shingles to choose from.
Winner: Architectural Shingles — If you prefer your roofing to match your home and boost curb appeal, then Architectural Shingles is the obvious winner.
Durability and Lifespan
3-Tab Shingles
In most cases, they last from 15–20 years under normal conditions. They are less sturdy and more likely to be damaged by high winds, heavy rain and hail in Arkansas.
Architectural Shingles
Thicker and heavier, these shingles can endure 25-30 years or longer. They tolerate wind (up to 110–130 mph), UV disintegration and impact better.
Winner: Architectural Shingles — With better longevity and resistance to the elements, these are the longer-term value products.
Warranty Coverage
3-Tab Shingles
Mostly, 3-Tab Shingles come with shorter manufacturer warranties.
Architectural Shingles
These shingles typically include limited lifetime warranties, and some involve extended warranties when installed by qualified contractors.
Winner: Architectural Shingles — More coverage and less worry.
Cost vs. Value
3-Tab Shingles
More affordable upfront, appealing for budget-conscious setups, or for temporary solutions.
Architectural Shingles
These shingles are a bit more expensive but logitivty and robustness make them worthy.
Winner: Architectural Shingles — Yes, the upfront cost is more, however, the life expectancy, the additional performance and the value they add to your home more than make up for it.
Resale Value
When you're ready to sell, a new roof with architectural shingles can also be a major selling point. Buyers like the extra durability and updated appearance, which might help your home sell faster — and for more money.
Winner: Architectural Shingles — Good for resale and property value.
Also Read: Why Annual Roof Inspections Are Essential for Homeowners?
The Verdict: Yes, Architectural Shingles Are Worth The Upgrade
3-tab shingles may still be appropriate for your project, especially if you are working on a tight budget, or something you don't consider your permanent home (a shed or garage), but if you want to add comfort and curb appeal to your property once and for all, architectural shingles are the clear winner.
At Rock Management Roofing, we are happy to suggest architectural shingles to customers who are looking for the best overall value in a roof.
Ready to upgrade your roof? Call us today for a free estimate, or to have some information on the best shingles for your home.
